The Advantages of Servlets Over “Traditional” CGI

By: aathishankaran  

The Advantages of Servlets Over “Traditional” CGI

 

Java servlets are more efficient, easier to use, more powerful, more portable, safer, and cheaper than traditional CGI and many alternative CGI-like technologies.

 

Efficient

 

With traditional CGI, a new process is started for each HTTP request. If the CGI program itself is relatively short, the overhead of starting the process can dominate the execution time. With servlets, the Java Virtual Machine stays running and handles each request using a lightweight Java thread, not a heavyweight operating system process. Similarly, in traditional CGI, if there are N simultaneous requests to the same CGI program, the code for the CGI program is loaded into memory N times. With servlets, however, there would be N threads but only a single copy of the servlet class. Finally, when a CGI program finishes handling a request, the program terminates. This makes it difficult to cache computations, keep database connections open, and perform other optimizations that rely on persistent data. Servlets, however, remain in memory even after they complete a response, so it is straightforward to store arbitrarily complex data between requests.

 

Convenient

 

Servlets have an extensive infrastructure for automatically parsing and decoding HTML form data, reading and setting HTTP headers, handling cookies, tracking sessions, and many other such high-level utilities. Besides, you already know the Java programming language. Why learn Perl too? You’re already convinced that Java technology makes for more reliable and reusable code than does C++. Why go back to C++ for server-side programming?

 

Powerful

 

Servlets support several capabilities that are difficult or impossible to accomplish with regular CGI. Servlets can talk directly to the Web server, whereas regular CGI programs cannot, at least not without using a server-specific API. Communicating with the Web server makes it easier to translate relative URLs into concrete path names, for instance. Multiple servlets can also share data, making it easy to implement database connection pooling and similar resource-sharing optimizations. Servlets can also maintain information from request to request, simplifying techniques like session tracking and caching of previous computations.

 

Portable

 

Servlets are written in the Java programming language and follow a standard API. Consequently, servlets written for, say, I-Planet Enterprise Server can run virtually unchanged on Apache, Microsoft Internet Information Server (IIS), IBM Web Sphere, or Star Nine Web Star. For example, virtually all of the servlets and JSP pages in this book were executed on Sun’s Java Web

Server, Apache Tomcat and Sun’s Java Server Web Development Kit (JSWDK) with no changes whatsoever in the code. Many were tested on BEA Web Logic and IBM Web Sphere as well. In fact, servlets are supported directly or by a plug-in on virtually every major Web server. They are now part of the Java 2 Platform, Enterprise Edition (), so industry support for servlets is becoming even more pervasive.

 

Secure

 

One of the main sources of vulnerabilities in traditional CGI programs stems from the fact that general-purpose operating system shells often execute them. So the CGI programmer has to be very careful to filter out characters such as back quotes and semicolons that are treated specially by the shell. This is harder than one might think, and weaknesses stemming from this problem are constantly being uncovered in widely used CGI libraries. A second source of problems is the fact that languages that do not automatically check array or string bounds process some CGI programs. For example, in C and C++ it is perfectly legal to allocate a 100-element array then write into the 999th “element,” which is really some random part of program memory. So programmers who forget to do this check themselves open their system up to deliberate or accidental buffer overflow attacks. Servlets suffer from neither of these problems. Even if a servlet executes a remote system call to invoke a program on the local operating system, it does not use a shell to do so. And of course array bounds checking and other memory protection features are a central part of the Java programming language.

 

Inexpensive

 

There are a number of free or very inexpensive Web servers available that are good for “personal” use or low-volume Web sites. However, with the major exception of Apache, which is free, most commercial-quality Web servers are relatively expensive. Nevertheless, once you have a Web server, no matter its cost, adding servlet support to it (if it doesn’t come pre configured to support servlets) costs very little extra. This is in contrast to many of the other CGI alternatives, which require a significant initial investment to purchase a proprietary package.

 

 

Archived Comments